Top Prospect Alert

AZFall Home

Archives

E-mail

 

 

 

AZ Fall League Scouting Report

2004 season

Final Report
December 28, 2003

American League West

Tommy Murphy
Tommy Murphy

Angels - Tommy Murphy (OF) is re-asserting himself as a prospect after a position change to the outfield from shortstop. He demonstrated good on-base skills and an effective slap hitting approach while batting .329/.400/.430 with eight SBs ... Nick Gorneault (OF) got on base with regularity (.387) but didn't do much else, as he managed only three extra-base hits and struck out 26 times in 74 ABs ... Casey Smith (SS/2B) was a bit of a surprise in a utility role for the champion Desert Dogs, playing well defensively at three positions. He didn't provide a lot of offense (.269/.321/.327), but put the ball in play. He may be able to make the big leagues in the 25th roster spot ... Mike Napoli (C/1B) can hit the ball very far. He also strikes out a lot, but knows the value of taking a walk. Napoli's numbers were solid at .284/.415/.433. He'll make the big jump to AA next year at the age of 23 ... A pair of southpaws, Dusty Bergman (P) and Jonathan Rouwenhorst (P), both struggled with their command out of the Phoenix bullpen. Bergman especially got hit hard (.405 opposition batting average).

Huston Street
Huston Street

A's - Arguably, the most impressive performer in the 2005 AFL season was former Texas Longhorn closer Huston Street (P). The right-hander give up only two runs in 18.1 IPs, tying for the league lead in ERA with 0.98; he struck out 19 and walked only two batters. Some ML scouts claimed that Oakland would have won the AL West had they called up Street during the stretch run. While he's not overpowering, Street gets the job done with business-life efficiency. It'll be a real surprise if he doesn't make the big league squad out of spring training ... Omar Quintanilla (SS) was a sparkplug for the Desert Dogs all season long, batting .374/.404/.527, and then came a homerun short of the cycle in the championship game. What's not to like about this little guy? He puts the ball in play, has surprising gap power and plays strong defense. He'll probably move to second base some day and may wind up being the Oakland starter at that position. At worst, he'll be a valuable utility infielder ... Jason Perry (OF) is an Eric Byrnes clone who did well in the AFL, batting .229/.316/.471 with five HRs in 70 ABs. He's already 24, so a big season as he moves to AAA in 2005 will be important ... Jeremy Brown (C) didn't get much playing time as the Desert Dogs' taxi squad catcher, but he batted .353/.477/.647 in 34 ABs and showed uncharacteristic power. Maybe this "Moneyball" thing isn't such a bad idea after all ... John Baker (C) got on the field a little more than Brown and did decently, batting .318/.404/.477 ... While not possessing impressive stuff, Steve Obenchain (P) pitched effectively for the Desert Dogs, finishing with a 3.71 ERA.

Mike Morse
Mike Morse

Mariners - Mike Morse (SS) came to the AFL to improve his defense; he left with the knowledge that he proved his point that a big man can play the position, making only four errors in 24 games and looking surprisingly agile around the bag. His offensive numbers weren't up to snuff, as he batted only .258/.296/.301, tailing off significantly late in the season. But he was there to work on his glovework --- mission accomplished ... Shin-soo Choo (OF) was impressive, batting .301/.422/.466 and showing advanced hitting skills by walking 14 times as opposed to his 11 strikeouts. He also won admirers with his aggressive play in the outfield. Choo may be in Seattle by mid-season ... Greg Dobbs (3B) was making up for lost time this year after having missed virtually all of the entire 2003 season to injury. He didn't show a lot of power from the left side, batting .292/.339/.377, but put the ball in play regularly. He's now blocked in Seattle after the signing of Adrian Beltre, so Dobbs may become trade bait with a strong start in AAA ... Southpaw reliever Jared Thomas (P) didn't follow up on his good AA season. When he wasn't walking AFL hitters, he was getting pounded by them. Chalk this one up to a learning experience ... Brett Evert (P) pitched better than his 7.43 ERA would indicate, as opposing batters hit only .255 and he yielded only six walks in 23 IPs ... Jon Huber (P) fanned 27 batters in 28 IPs, but opponents batted .299 off him.

Ian Kinsler
Ian Kinsler

Rangers - The biggest surprise story of the 2004 season continued in the AFL as Ian Kinsler (SS) batted .306/.369/.500 with four HRs in 108 ABs. The hitting skills are there, so Kinsler's breakout season was no fluke ... Jason Botts put up very nice batting stats (.355/.461/.570, six HRs, 21 BBs in 107 ABs). Strikeouts are still a problem, as he fanned 32 times. His conversion to the outfielder was successful, as he demonstrated decent range for a big man ... (OF) Juan Senreiso (OF) is a five-tool talent who had a decent season at three levels (Low A, High A, AA) in 2005, but it didn't carry over into the AFL. The native Dominican batted .181/.274/.289. It wasn't a totally lost season, as Senreiso worked on improving his plate discipline and drew 10 walks in 83 ABs ... John Hudgins (P) struggled in the AFL, as opponents batted .357 off him ... Matt Lorenzo (P) turned in a surprising performance, finishing with a 2.63 ERA and earning Pitcher of the Week honors late in the season. He walked only six batters in 24 IPs ... Wes Littleton (P) was effective, with a 1.15 WHIP and a 2.65 ERA ...

--- Bill Mitchell

Next page

Player reports by team
AL East / AL Central / AL West
NL East / NL Central / NL West

AZFall Home / Archives